Every championship-caliber team eventually reveals the same truth: stars matter, but core players matter more. The ones who stabilize systems. The ones whose impact shows up across multiple layers of the game. The ones who don’t just produce, but elevate the structure around them.
When Oklahoma enters the 2026 season, the Sooners’ internal foundation will be unusually clear. This isn’t a roster built around one transcendent name or a single position group. It’s built around a trio that touches every phase of the sport:
- John Mateer, the quarterback and offensive engine
- Isaiah Sategna, the offensive multiplier and field-position weapon
- Kip Lewis, the defensive backbone and schematic anchor
Together, they form Oklahoma’s most valuable asset: continuity with upside.
And when you study their advanced metrics, the picture becomes even sharper. This isn’t just a “good returning group.” It’s a core whose statistical profiles suggest Oklahoma’s floor is already high — and its ceiling is legitimately national.
John Mateer: The Quarterback with a Hidden Growth Curve
On paper, Mateer’s 2025 season looks solid: 2,885 passing yards, 22 total touchdowns, a QBR of 65.1, and a trip to the College Football Playoff. That’s already enough to qualify as a successful year.
But the advanced metrics tell a more nuanced — and more promising — story.
Mateer’s season was effectively split in two by a mid-year hand injury that required surgery. Before it, his efficiency metrics looked like those of a breakout quarterback. After it, his production flattened, dragging down his season-long averages.
That context matters because even with the injury, Mateer still finished:
- 44th nationally in passing yards
- Top 50 in QBR
- With 431 rushing yards and 8 rushing touchdowns
From an analytical standpoint, the most intriguing part of his profile is how he produced.
According to PFF data, Mateer ranked No. 4 nationally in passer rating under pressure. That’s elite. It suggests a quarterback who remains effective when the play breaks down — something that cannot be taught easily.
At the same time, he also ranked near the top in turnover-worthy plays when kept clean. That paradox points to a quarterback still learning situational discipline — not one lacking physical tools.
In other words, Mateer already has the hardest traits to develop:
- Comfort under chaos
- Mobility as a real weapon
- Big-game functionality
What remains is refinement, not reinvention. And refinement is exactly what returning quarterbacks usually achieve.
For Oklahoma, that’s enormous. The Sooners don’t just get experience back. They get a quarterback whose advanced profile suggests statistical growth is more likely than regression.
Isaiah Sategna: The Efficiency Engine of the Offense
If Mateer is the engine, Isaiah Sategna is the transmission.
Traditional stats already paint Sategna as Oklahoma’s top weapon: 67 receptions, 965 yards, eight touchdowns, plus over 300 punt return yards. But the advanced metrics reveal why his value goes far beyond volume.
Sategna finished with 103 targets, the most on the team. Targets represent trust — where the quarterback goes when structure breaks down. And despite operating primarily on short and intermediate routes, he still averaged nearly 15 yards per catch.
Here’s where the analytics become decisive:
- 50 of his 67 catches came within nine yards of the line of scrimmage
- He averaged over 6 yards after catch on those throws
- On third down, he averaged 21.9 yards per reception
That combination makes Sategna a rare profile: a high-volume receiver who creates explosive plays without needing deep shots. Oklahoma essentially turned him into a hybrid between a receiver and a space player.
From a team-value perspective, this is critical.
Sategna allowed Oklahoma to:
- Stay aggressive without forcing risky throws
- Generate explosive gains from safe concepts
- Flip field position through punt returns
He finished with 1,307 all-purpose yards, ranking among the most valuable total contributors in the SEC.
Even his flaws show up constructively in the data. His drop rate (8.2%) was higher than ideal — but that’s also a byproduct of elite usage. High-touch players accumulate drops because they operate in tight windows under real defensive attention.
The advanced metrics don’t describe a gadget player. They describe a foundational offensive piece — one who sustains drives, creates hidden yards, and raises efficiency across the entire system.
When paired with a quarterback like Mateer, Sategna becomes something even more dangerous: a safety valve that also generates explosives.
Take a Deeper Dive With Our 2026 Oklahoma Football Content
Available exclusively on our Facebook subscription page
– John Mateer by the Metrics
– Kip Lewis, Oklahoma’s Defensive Foundation
– Isaiah Sategna Was Even Better Than He Looked in 2025
Kip Lewis: The Statistical Backbone of the Defense
While Mateer and Sategna drive Oklahoma’s offense, Kip Lewis quietly defines the structure of its defense.
Lewis led the team with 76 tackles, added 10.5 tackles for loss, and recorded four sacks. But those are surface-level indicators.
The advanced metrics are where his real value appears:
- 77.2 overall PFF grade (top five among SEC linebackers)
- 85.1 run defense grade (elite)
- 39 “stops” (fourth in the SEC)
- 20 total pressures as an inside linebacker
Stops are particularly revealing. They measure plays that directly harm the offense — tackles on failed downs, short-yardage losses, drive-killing moments. Lewis wasn’t just active. He was decisive.
From a schematic standpoint, Lewis gives Oklahoma rare flexibility:
- He can anchor the run defense
- He can blitz effectively
- He can survive in coverage
- He understands the system at a veteran level
His development curve is just as important as his raw numbers. His PFF grades have climbed every season, suggesting he hasn’t peaked — he’s still ascending.
That’s why his return might be Oklahoma’s most underrated offseason win.
Defenses often collapse from the middle outward. Lewis prevents that. He stabilizes alignments, communication, and run fits — the invisible infrastructure of elite defense.
There is no metric for leadership. But there are plenty for defensive efficiency. And Lewis ranks near the top in all of them.
The Real Value: Systemic Continuity
Individually, Mateer, Sategna, and Lewis are high-level players.
Collectively, they do something far more valuable: they lock Oklahoma’s identity into place.
- The quarterback knows the system.
- The primary weapon understands timing and spacing.
- The defensive centerpiece controls the middle.
That kind of continuity is rare in modern college football — and it’s exactly what allows teams to make statistical leaps instead of starting over.
From a team-building perspective, Oklahoma doesn’t need miracles in 2026. It needs marginal gains:
- Mateer cuts down a few turnovers.
- Sategna trims the drop rate.
- Lewis continues his development curve.
None of those require talent breakthroughs. They require health, experience, and refinement — all of which are already in place.
Final Verdict: Oklahoma’s Floor Is High — and the Ceiling Is Real
Most preseason contenders rely on projection. Oklahoma relies on proof.
The advanced metrics say this trio already:
- Produces efficiently
- Performs against elite competition
- Impacts multiple phases of the game
- Shows sustainable statistical profiles
That’s the difference between hype and foundation.
John Mateer gives Oklahoma stability with upside.
Isaiah Sategna gives it efficiency with explosiveness.
Kip Lewis gives it structure with reliability.
Together, they form one of the most analytically sound cores in the SEC.
Not just because they’re talented — but because the numbers say their impact is real, repeatable, and central to how Oklahoma wins football games in 2026.
Follow us on Instagram & Facebook