With just two weeks remaining in the regular season, the Big 12 race is becoming a two-team battle at the top, with Utah and Texas Tech emerging as the conference’s clear front-runners. Behind them, BYU is still clinging to its championship hopes, while the battle for positioning throughout the rest of the league remains wide open.
Week 11 delivered another eventful Saturday. Utah survived a wild 40–39 road thriller against Arizona, preserving its unbeaten conference record and maintaining control of its path to Arlington. Texas Tech, meanwhile, made its strongest statement of the season, dismantling Oklahoma State 52–27 in Stillwater to strengthen its position as Utah’s primary challenger.
BYU kept its championship hopes alive with a convincing 28–7 victory over Baylor, while Colorado provided one of the weekend’s biggest surprises by knocking off No. 14 Houston. Kansas also picked up an important victory, taking down West Virginia 37–14 and creating even more movement in the bottom half of the rankings.
With the regular season entering its final two weeks, the margin for error is disappearing. Utah and Texas Tech control their championship destinies, BYU needs some help, and several other programs are simply trying to finish the season on a positive note.
Our three voters are in complete agreement on the top three, but things get considerably more interesting after that. Here is how Caleb, Matt, and Zack rank all 16 Big 12 programs heading into Week 12.
Big 12 Week 12 Consensus Power Rankings
Each team receives 16 points for a first-place vote, 15 for second, and so on, down to one point for a 16th-place vote. The maximum possible score is 48 points.
| Rank | Team | Points |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Utah | 48 |
| 2 | Texas Tech | 45 |
| 3 | BYU | 42 |
| 4 | Arizona | 39 |
| 5 | Houston | 35 |
| 6 | Oklahoma State | 34 |
| 7 | Baylor | 29 |
| 8 | Arizona State | 26 |
| 9 | Iowa State | 25 |
| 10 | TCU | 20 |
| T-11 | West Virginia | 15 |
| T-11 | UCF | 15 |
| 13 | Cincinnati | 12 |
| 14 | Colorado | 11 |
| 15 | Kansas | 9 |
| 16 | Kansas State | 3 |
The Big Three: Utah, Texas Tech and BYU Separate Themselves
There isn’t a single disagreement among our voters regarding the top three.
Utah receives all three first-place votes to earn a perfect 48 points. Texas Tech follows with 45 points, while BYU rounds out the top three with 42.
The Utes remain the team everyone is chasing. Surviving Arizona’s late-game push wasn’t pretty, but championship teams find ways to win difficult games. Utah is still undefeated in conference play and needs just one more victory to secure its place in the Big 12 Championship Game.
Texas Tech is making its own compelling argument. The Red Raiders’ 52–27 dismantling of Oklahoma State was arguably their most impressive performance of the season. Their offense is clicking, and they have positioned themselves to challenge Utah for the conference crown.
BYU remains third, although its path to Arlington is considerably more complicated. The Cougars took care of Baylor, but they need to win their remaining games and get help from Texas Tech. All three of us recognize that BYU remains one of the conference’s best teams.
Caleb
BYU handled Baylor 28-7, showing how dangerous its defense can be. The Cougars have the resume to remain among the conference’s top teams.
Matt
The Cougars have bounced back decisively from their rivalry loss to Utah by suffocating Baylor’s offense in a 28–7 victory. Sitting at No. 10 in the CFP rankings, BYU remains firmly in the at-large playoff conversation and can still reach the conference title game if it wins out and Texas Tech stumbles.
Zack
The Cougars took care of Baylor this last weekend to keep their Big 12 Championship hopes alive. BYU has to win out, and Texas Tech has to lose a game in order for the two teams to finish tied in conference play. The Cougars hold the tiebreaker, but regardless of what the Red Raiders do, BYU has to win.
The separation between these three and the rest of the league is becoming increasingly apparent.
The Contenders: Arizona, Houston and Oklahoma State
Arizona holds the No. 4 position with 39 points, despite coming painfully close to knocking off Utah. All three of us have the Wildcats fourth, demonstrating complete agreement about their standing.
Houston follows at No. 5 with 35 points, just ahead of Oklahoma State at No. 6 with 34.
The Cougars’ loss to Colorado was a significant setback, but we haven’t completely abandoned them. Caleb and Matt both rank Houston fifth, while Zack has the Cougars sixth.
Oklahoma State is right behind Houston. Caleb and Matt have the Cowboys sixth, while Zack places them fifth.
Baylor occupies the No. 7 position with 29 points. Arizona State follows at eighth with 26, while Iowa State rounds out the top nine with 25.
These three programs are separated by only four points, illustrating just how crowded the middle of the conference has become.
The Middle Class: TCU Holds Its Position as West Virginia and UCF Tie
TCU checks in at No. 10 with 20 points. We’re all pretty close with the Horned Frogs this week. Caleb and Matt have them at 10th and Zack puts them at 11th, making this another relatively narrow consensus.
West Virginia and UCF are tied for 11th with 15 points apiece, although they arrived there through very different paths.
West Virginia is ranked as high as ninth by Zack but falls to 15th on Matt’s ballot. UCF, meanwhile, receives 11th-place votes from Caleb and Matt, but Zack drops the Knights to 14th.
Cincinnati comes in at No. 13 with 12 points. The Bearcats have a relatively consistent placement, receiving rankings of 13th, 14th, and 12th.
Colorado follows at No. 14 with 11 points. The Buffaloes’ upset of Houston earned them some respect, but we’re remaining cautious about elevating a team that has struggled with consistency throughout the season.
The Bottom: Kansas Moves Up, Kansas State Remains in Last
Kansas lands at No. 15 with nine points, despite its impressive victory over West Virginia.
Zack is the least optimistic about the Jayhawks, placing them 15th, while Caleb and Matt have them 14th and 13th, respectively.
Kansas State remains firmly at the bottom with just three points. All three of us have the Wildcats 16th.
Caleb
Kansas State remains at the bottom after losing 20-10 to TCU. The Wildcats have struggled to find consistency and haven’t done enough in conference play to move up.
Matt
Stuck at the bottom of the Big 12 standings, the Wildcats are mired in a four-game losing streak following a 20–10 defeat against TCU. Unable to generate consistent offense in conference play, Kansas State must pull off upsets in both of its remaining games to avoid missing a bowl.
Zack
The Wildcats have hit their version of rock bottom. Yes, they hold a head-to-head win over Kansas, but the Jayhawks look like the better football team today, and Kansas State is not likely to win either of their two remaining games (home vs. Arizona and on the road at Iowa State).
The Wildcats have struggled throughout conference play and are currently mired in a four-game losing streak. Their head-to-head victory over Kansas earlier in the season isn’t enough to convince any of us that they’re the better team right now.
Individual Rankings
Caleb’s Rankings
1. Utah — The Utes remain the clear No. 1 after surviving a thrilling 40-39 win over Arizona. They are still undefeated in conference play and the team everyone else is chasing.
2. Texas Tech — The Red Raiders made a statement with a dominant 52-27 win over Oklahoma State. Their explosive offense makes them Utah’s biggest challenger.
3. BYU — BYU handled Baylor 28-7, showing how dangerous its defense can be. The Cougars have the resume to remain among the conference’s top teams.
4. Arizona
5. Houston
6. Oklahoma State
7. Arizona State
8. Baylor
9. Iowa State
10. TCU
11. UCF
12. West Virginia
13. Cincinnati
14. Kansas
15. Colorado — Colorado deserves credit for pulling off a 42-32 upset over Houston. However, one impressive win doesn’t erase the inconsistency that has defined its season.
16. Kansas State — Kansas State remains at the bottom after losing 20-10 to TCU. The Wildcats have struggled to find consistency and haven’t done enough in conference play to move up.
Matt’s Rankings
1. Utah — The Utes remain the Big 12’s lone unbeaten squad and sit at No. 2 in the College Football Playoff rankings. Even after a multi-hour travel delay and a fierce road test in Tucson, Utah found a way to survive 40–39 against Arizona and controls its own destiny to clinch a berth in Arlington.
2. Texas Tech — Playing arguably the sharpest football in the conference right now, the Red Raiders dismantled Oklahoma State 52–27 on the road in Week 11. With wins over Houston and Arizona already in hand, Texas Tech holds the inside track to face Utah in the Big 12 Championship Game.
3. BYU — The Cougars have bounced back decisively from their rivalry loss to Utah by suffocating Baylor’s offense in a 28–7 victory. Sitting at No. 10 in the CFP rankings, BYU remains firmly in the at-large playoff conversation and can still reach the conference title game if it wins out and Texas Tech stumbles.
4. Arizona
5. Houston
6. Oklahoma State
7. Baylor
8. Arizona State
9. Iowa State
10. TCU
11. UCF
12. Colorado
13. Kansas
14. Cincinnati
15. West Virginia — The Mountaineers have tumbled down the league hierarchy after dropping back-to-back games, capped by a lopsided 37–14 home loss to Kansas. Defensive breakdowns and sudden offensive stagnation have left West Virginia scrambling just to salvage bowl eligibility over the final two weeks.
16. Kansas State — Stuck at the bottom of the Big 12 standings, the Wildcats are mired in a four-game losing streak following a 20–10 defeat against TCU. Unable to generate consistent offense in conference play, Kansas State must pull off upsets in both of its remaining games to avoid missing a bowl.
Zack’s Rankings
1. Utah — It wasn’t easy, but Utah pulled out the road win against Arizona, and now, they are all but certain to be in the Big 12 Championship. If they win just one of their final 2 games, they’re in, but the Utes will likely be heavily favored both at TCU and at home against West Virginia.
2. Texas Tech — The Red Raiders picked up their most impressive win of the season by absolutely dominating the Cowboys in Stillwater. They’re not a lock by any means to make it to the Big 12 Championship, but if they win out, they’re in. They have to take on Baylor on the road next weekend before hosting TCU, and while neither is an easy win, the Red Raiders will be favored in both.
3. BYU — The Cougars took care of Baylor this last weekend to keep their Big 12 Championship hopes alive. BYU has to win out, and Texas Tech has to lose a game in order for the two teams to finish tied in conference play. The Cougars hold the tiebreaker, but regardless of what the Red Raiders do, BYU has to win.
4. Arizona
5. Oklahoma State
6. Houston
7. Baylor
8. Iowa State
9. West Virginia
10. Arizona State
11. TCU
12. Cincinnati
13. Colorado
14. UCF
15. Kansas — The Jayhawks finally got another conference win, and it was a doozy. West Virginia is closer to the bottom of the Big 12 than the top, but Kansas managed to hold the Mountaineers to just 14 points, which is wildly impressive. Still, it’s hard to move Kansas up more than one spot.
16. Kansas State — The Wildcats have hit their version of rock bottom. Yes, they hold a head-to-head win over Kansas, but the Jayhawks look like the better football team today, and Kansas State is not likely to win either of their two remaining games (home vs. Arizona and on the road at Iowa State).
Where We Agree — And Where We Don’t
The Week 12 ballots reveal a remarkable amount of agreement at the top, but there are some significant differences once we get past the conference’s leading contenders.
The biggest areas of agreement
– Utah, Texas Tech and BYU: Complete agreement. All three of us have the same top three in the same order. Utah receives 48 points, Texas Tech 45, and BYU 42. That’s about as definitive as consensus gets.
– Arizona: All three of us place the Wildcats fourth. Despite the heartbreaking loss to Utah, nobody is questioning Arizona’s place among the conference’s best.
– Houston and Oklahoma State: Both teams receive remarkably consistent rankings. Houston is fifth on two ballots and sixth on the other, while Oklahoma State is sixth on two ballots and fifth on the other.
– Kansas State: Another unanimous selection, although not one the Wildcats will appreciate. All three of us have Kansas State 16th.
– TCU: Caleb and Matt both place the Horned Frogs 10th, while Zack has them 11th. There’s very little disagreement about where TCU belongs.
Where we were way off
West Virginia is the biggest disagreement.
Matt has the Mountaineers 15th, Caleb places them 12th, and Zack ranks them ninth. That’s a six-position difference between the highest and lowest rankings.
Zack clearly hasn’t given up on West Virginia despite the recent struggles, while Matt believes the Mountaineers have fallen into the bottom tier of the conference following consecutive defeats.
Arizona State is another interesting disagreement.
Caleb has the Sun Devils seventh, Matt puts them eighth, and Zack drops them to 10th. While the difference isn’t quite as dramatic as West Virginia, it shows that we’re not entirely sure where Arizona State belongs in the crowded middle.
Colorado also generates some debate.
Zack has the Buffaloes 13th, Matt places them 12th, and Caleb drops them to 15th. The upset over Houston clearly made an impression, but Caleb remains skeptical that Colorado has turned a corner.
Kansas is another area of disagreement.
Matt is the most optimistic about the Jayhawks, placing them 13th. Caleb has them 14th, while Zack puts them 15th. The victory over West Virginia was impressive, but Zack isn’t ready to elevate Kansas significantly based on one performance.
Ultimately, our biggest disagreements are concentrated in the middle and lower portions of the conference. We have a very clear picture of the top four, but the teams from fifth through 15th remain difficult to separate.
Final Thoughts
The Big 12 title race is approaching its conclusion, and Utah continues to look like the team to beat.
The Utes have survived their toughest remaining road challenge and are now one victory away from officially securing their place in Arlington. Texas Tech is playing its best football at the right time, and the Red Raiders have an opportunity to make the championship matchup official by winning their final two games.
BYU remains the wild card. The Cougars have the talent and résumé to compete for a championship, but their margin for error is gone.
Behind those three, Arizona remains firmly established as a top-four program, while Houston, Oklahoma State, Baylor, and Arizona State are fighting for positioning in an increasingly crowded middle tier.
For Colorado and Kansas, Week 11 provided some much-needed momentum. Meanwhile, West Virginia and Kansas State are running out of opportunities to salvage their seasons.
Two weeks remain. The road to Arlington is getting shorter, and the stakes are getting higher.
Utah is in control. Texas Tech is closing in. And BYU is waiting for an opportunity to crash the party.

