As the 2025 college football season approaches, the Oklahoma Sooners find themselves at a crossroads. Entering Year 2 in the Southeastern Conference and Year 4 under Brent Venables, Team 131 has the potential to be one of the nation’s biggest surprises—or one of its most disappointing letdowns. And the difference between those two extremes likely hinges on three things: John Mateer, Ben Arbuckle, and whether Venables’ defense can once again hold the line.
Let’s not sugarcoat it: 2024 was a disappointment. Oklahoma went 6–7 in its first SEC season, with glaring issues on the offensive side of the ball, inconsistent quarterback play, and an offensive line that failed to protect anyone. Injuries played a role, but in a conference as deep and grueling as the SEC, there are no excuses—only results.
The Wildcard of 2025
Which brings us to now: a retooled roster, a new quarterback, a new offensive coordinator, and a schedule that ranks among the most brutal in the country.
And yet, somehow, optimism has returned to Norman.
CBS Sports and 247Sports have labeled Oklahoma a “wildcard” team entering the season—one capable of finishing anywhere from 6–6 to College Football Playoff contention. Why? Because while the schedule remains stacked (with games against Michigan, Texas, LSU, Ole Miss, and Alabama), Oklahoma looks like a significantly improved team.
John Mateer, the former Washington State quarterback, is a massive part of that. He isn’t just another transfer arm. He’s a dynamic dual-threat signal caller who threw for over 3,100 yards and rushed for 826 more last season. His 44 total touchdowns at Wazzu came behind a mediocre offensive line, and now he arrives in Norman as the potential savior of the offense.
Combine that with the hiring of Ben Arbuckle, one of the brightest young offensive coordinators in the game, and the Sooners may finally have the creative spark they’ve lacked since Lincoln Riley’s departure. Arbuckle made waves at Western Kentucky and Washington State for producing explosive, balanced attacks. Now he inherits a skill group that includes dynamic back Jaydn Ott (1,300+ yards in 2023), a talented if underdeveloped receiver room, and an offensive line that, while shaky last season, has seen important additions and internal development.
The Known Commodity: Venables’ Defense
While the offense feels new and uncertain, the defense offers consistency. That’s Brent Venables’ calling card, and in 2024, it was the one unit that kept the Sooners afloat. Now entering his fourth year, Venables finally has the personnel, scheme familiarity, and depth needed to compete defensively in the SEC.
Players like R Mason Thomas, Damonic Williams, Gracen Halton, and Jayden Jackson form the backbone of a defensive line that ranks among the top 10 nationally according to Pro Football Focus. Add in Marvin Jones Jr. off the edge, rising stars like Danny Okoye, and a linebacker room that returns major experience, and you can begin to believe the defense is playoff-caliber.
So if the Sooners are going to surprise people, this is how it happens: a top-tier defense keeps games close, and a revitalized offense powered by Mateer and Arbuckle turns just enough corners to make Oklahoma a contender.
But Make No Mistake: The Pressure is On
This isn’t just about talent or potential anymore. For Brent Venables, 2025 is a must-win year—not necessarily in terms of championships, but certainly in perception and direction. He’s now entering Year 4 with two losing seasons under his belt. And while his contract extension (worth over $8.5 million annually with a nearly $35 million buyout) gives him some protection, even the friendliest administrators eventually run out of patience when results don’t follow vision.
Critics like Paul Finebaum have made it clear: another six-win season won’t cut it. And while Venables has a strong ally in athletic director Joe Castiglione, the SEC isn’t a conference that rewards sentimentality. Just ask Dan Mullen or Ed Orgeron.
The good news? The Sooners are better on paper. The injuries that plagued the wide receiver and offensive line rooms last season were a major setback. Those units are now healthier and deeper. Recruiting has picked up again. The transfer portal was kind. And unlike last year, Oklahoma has answers—at quarterback, at running back, and along the front seven.
The Litmus Test: Michigan in Week 2
All eyes will be on Week 2, when Oklahoma hosts Michigan in one of the biggest non-conference games of the season. Win that game, and the Sooners will suddenly be the talk of the country. They could enter the Red River Rivalry at 5–0, with momentum, swagger, and belief.
Lose that game, and it doesn’t doom the season—but it would certainly raise the pressure for the SEC opener against Auburn two weeks later.
In a year when preseason projections range from fourth to 11th in the SEC, it’s clear the Sooners are hard to pin down. But one thing is certain: they have a much higher ceiling than they did a year ago.
The Final Word
Oklahoma football in 2025 is both a riddle and a reckoning. The team is improved. The quarterback room is better. The offensive system has more potential. And the defense is solid. But the schedule is unrelenting, and the margin for error is razor thin.
For Venables, for Mateer, and for Sooner Nation, 2025 offers something that 2024 didn’t: hope with teeth.
Now, it’s time to find out whether all that potential turns into results. Because if not? The noise around the Brent Venables era will only grow louder.
And in the SEC, there’s not a lot of time—or sympathy—for noise without wins.
Follow us on Instagram