We took a tumble again last weekend.
Matt gave us the only winning record at 2-1, while Caleb, Craig, and Zack all finished at 1-2. Sure, it brings an end to a good run, but for the second weekend in a row nobody got shut out and the Cone of Shame stays on the shelf. Hey, at this point, we’ll take anything positive that we can get.
Week 12 brings us three popular picks, with BYU, Texas Tech, and Tennessee each getting multiple votes. The BYU game might be the most interesting, though, because while three of us are backing the Cougars, Matt is taking Kansas to keep things close.
Let’s see if we can get back on track.
BYU Gets Three Votes Against Kansas
BYU is the most popular pick on the board this week, with Caleb, Craig, and Zack all backing the Cougars to cover the 5.5-point spread against Kansas.
The Jayhawks are coming off a big win over West Virginia, but our three BYU supporters believe the Cougars have too much to offer on both sides of the football. BYU is still competing for a spot in the Big 12 Championship and has already shown it can beat quality opponents, including Notre Dame.
Craig expects BYU to end Kansas’ recent fun with a comfortable win in Lawrence, while Zack believes the Cougars should roll over the Jayhawks.
Matt, however, sees things differently. He’s taking Kansas and the points, believing the Jayhawks’ home-field advantage and mobile quarterback Isaiah Marshall can make this a much closer game than the other three expect.
Caleb: BYU -5.5
BYU enters its matchup against Kansas with a strong opportunity to control the game on both sides of the football. The Cougars have demonstrated that they can compete with quality opponents, highlighted by their impressive victory over Notre Dame. Defensively, BYU has the ability to make life difficult for Kansas, particularly if it can slow down the Jayhawks’ rushing attack and force them to become one-dimensional. If BYU establishes control at the line of scrimmage, limits Kansas’ offensive opportunities, and maintains consistent production offensively, the Cougars have a strong path to coming away with a convincing victory.
Craig: BYU -5.5
Kansas surprised everyone a week ago, which is why this spread is so close in my opinion. BYU will end the fun for the Jayhawks with an easy win in Lawrence.
Zack: BYU -5.5
The Jayhawks are coming off a big win over West Virginia, but the Cougars are coming off their own solid win over Baylor. BYU is also still in the hunt for a spot in the Big 12 Championship, and I feel like they should roll over Kansas easily.
Texas Tech Is a Popular Road Favorite
Texas Tech is another team getting plenty of support this weekend.
Craig and Zack are both taking the Red Raiders to cover the 3.5-point spread at Baylor. Texas Tech has responded to its loss with back-to-back impressive victories, and both guys believe the offense is playing well enough to take care of business in Waco.
Craig likes the way the Red Raiders have been rolling offensively and doesn’t see Baylor slowing them down. Zack is even more emphatic, pointing to Texas Tech’s dominant performance against Oklahoma State and his continued skepticism about Baylor’s record.
Craig: Texas Tech -3.5
Texas Tech responded to their loss with back-to-back big wins. This offense is on a roll right now, and I don’t see Baylor slowing them down.
Zack: Texas Tech -3.5
The Red Raiders are coming off their most impressive win of the season, mostly because they looked dominant at every aspect of the game. Meanwhile, I still think the Bears are held up by weak wins. I would not be surprised if Tech ran away with this one early.
Tennessee Has Two Believers Against LSU
The third consensus pick of the week comes from the SEC, where Tennessee hosts LSU.
Caleb and Craig are both taking the Volunteers as 1.5-point underdogs. That’s right: both are backing Tennessee to win outright, despite the Tigers being favored.
The case for the Vols starts with their defense. Tennessee is allowing just 14 points per game, seventh-best nationally, and has a significant advantage in turnover margin. The Volunteers also have a productive ground game led by DeSean Bishop, who has rushed for 1,163 yards and 13 touchdowns this season.
Craig admits he might have leaned toward LSU a week ago, but the recent direction of both programs has changed his mind. Caleb sees Tennessee’s defense and ability to create turnovers as the deciding factors.
Caleb: Tennessee +1.5
The Volunteers have been especially strong defensively, allowing just 14 points per game, which ranks seventh nationally. Their ability to create turnovers has also been a major strength, giving them a +8 turnover margin compared to LSU’s -4. Offensively, running back DeSean Bishop has been a difference-maker, totaling 1,163 rushing yards and 13 touchdowns this season.
Craig: Tennessee +1.5
A week ago I would have picked LSU. But, with the way each program is trending at the moment I’ve got to give it to the Vols at home.
Individual Picks
Caleb
BYU (-5.5) vs. Kansas
BYU enters its matchup against Kansas with a strong opportunity to control the game on both sides of the football. The Cougars have demonstrated that they can compete with quality opponents, highlighted by their impressive victory over Notre Dame. Defensively, BYU has the ability to make life difficult for Kansas, particularly if it can slow down the Jayhawks’ rushing attack and force them to become one-dimensional. If BYU establishes control at the line of scrimmage, limits Kansas’ offensive opportunities, and maintains consistent production offensively, the Cougars have a strong path to coming away with a convincing victory.
UCLA (-3.5) vs. Michigan
UCLA enters its matchup against Michigan with a significant advantage. The Bruins have been especially impressive defensively, leading the nation in takeaways and interceptions while ranking among the best teams at stopping the run. Michigan also faces some major injury concerns, with starting wide receiver JJ Buchanan and offensive tackles Blake Frazier and Andrew Sprague unavailable.
Tennessee (+1.5) vs. LSU
The Volunteers have been especially strong defensively, allowing just 14 points per game, which ranks seventh nationally. Their ability to create turnovers has also been a major strength, giving them a +8 turnover margin compared to LSU’s -4. Offensively, running back DeSean Bishop has been a difference-maker, totaling 1,163 rushing yards and 13 touchdowns this season.
Craig
BYU (-5.5) at Kansas
Kansas surprised everyone a week ago, which is why this spread is so close in my opinion. BYU will end the fun for the Jayhawks with an easy win in Lawrence.
Texas Tech (-3.5) at Baylor
Texas Tech responded to their loss with back-to-back big wins. This offense is on a roll right now, and I don’t see Baylor slowing them down.
Tennessee (+1.5) vs. LSU
A week ago I would have picked LSU. But, with the way each program is trending at the moment I’ve got to give it to the Vols at home.
Matt
Oregon (-16.5) at Michigan State
Michigan State enters tonight’s matchup without starting quarterback Alessio Milivojevic (out, arm), leaving a banged-up Cam Fancher or true freshman Kayd Coffman to pilot an offense that already averages just 18.8 points per game. Meanwhile, Ducks quarterback Dylan Raiola is playing his best football of the season—throwing nine touchdown passes over his last three games against a Spartans secondary ranked 98th nationally in passing efficiency allowed.
Kansas (+5.5) vs. BYU
Kansas is playing at home with maximum urgency to keep its bowl hopes alive, and mobile quarterback Isaiah Marshall has the exact rushing skillset needed to pick up key first downs, chew up the clock, and exploit a BYU defense built primarily to stop deep passes rather than scrambling quarterbacks.
Georgia Tech (+20.5) vs. Wake Forest
Wake Forest is clearly the stronger team, but big road favorites don’t always have to blow teams out to win, and a slow, run-heavy game at Bobby Dodd Stadium on Senior Day gives Georgia Tech plenty of ways to keep it close enough—or sneak in a late score—to stay inside that number.
Zack
BYU (-5.5) at Kansas
The Jayhawks are coming off a big win over West Virginia, but the Cougars are coming off their own solid win over Baylor. BYU is also still in the hunt for a spot in the Big 12 Championship, and I feel like they should roll over Kansas easily.
Texas Tech (-3.5) at Baylor
The Red Raiders are coming off their most impressive win of the season, mostly because they looked dominant at every aspect of the game. Meanwhile, I still think the Bears are held up by weak wins. I would not be surprised if Tech ran away with this one early.
Arizona (-7) at Kansas State
Even though Arizona lost last weekend, they gave Utah their toughest game of the season. I don’t see Kansas State keeping this one close after the way they have looked in conference play. I like the red and blue Wildcats to dominate the purple and white ones.
The Week 12 Heartland Sports Scorecard
It wasn’t a disastrous weekend, but it wasn’t exactly the kind of performance we were hoping for, either.
Here’s where everyone stands heading into Week 12:
| Rank | Writer | Week 11 | Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Caleb | 1-2 | 18-18 |
| T2 | Craig | 1-2 | 17-19 |
| T2 | Matt | 2-1 | 17-19 |
| 4 | Zack | 1-2 | 16-20 |
Week 12 Picks
| Writer | Pick No. 1 | Pick No. 2 | Pick No. 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Caleb | BYU -5.5 | UCLA -3.5 | Tennessee +1.5 |
| Craig | BYU -5.5 | Texas Tech -3.5 | Tennessee +1.5 |
| Matt | Oregon -16.5 | Kansas +5.5 | Georgia Tech +20.5 |
| Zack | BYU -5.5 | Texas Tech -3.5 | Arizona -7 |
Week 12 Storylines to Watch
Most Popular Pick: BYU
Three of our four huys are backing BYU against Kansas.
Caleb, Craig, and Zack all believe the Cougars have the advantage and should be able to cover the 5.5-point spread. BYU’s win over Notre Dame and its continued pursuit of a Big 12 Championship appearance give the Cougars plenty of motivation.
Matt is the lone holdout, believing Kansas can use its home-field advantage and mobile quarterback to keep the game close.
Texas Tech Gets the Road Support
Craig and Zack are both taking Texas Tech at Baylor.
The Red Raiders have put together back-to-back strong performances, and both guys believe their offense is playing at a level Baylor won’t be able to match. The difference between a close road win and a comfortable victory could determine just how good this pick looks by Saturday night.
Tennessee Is Getting the Underdog Love
Caleb and Craig are both taking Tennessee +1.5 against LSU.
The Volunteers have been excellent defensively, and their turnover margin gives them a significant statistical advantage heading into the matchup. Both writers believe Tennessee is trending in the right direction and can take advantage of playing at home.
Game of the Week: BYU vs. Kansas
This one has the potential to create some separation in the standings.
Caleb, Craig, and Zack are all backing BYU, while Matt is taking Kansas and the points. If the Cougars win comfortably, three writers will be celebrating. If Kansas keeps it close enough to cover, Matt will have a chance to gain ground on the rest of the group.
It’s the biggest house-divided matchup on the board, and we’ll be watching this one closely.
The Bounce-Back Watch
Nobody had a particularly great weekend, but Matt at least managed to finish above .500 and keep himself within one game of second place.
Caleb is looking to protect his lead, while Craig has a chance to pull even with him if things break the right way. Zack needs a strong weekend to avoid falling further behind.
And, of course, we’re all hoping to keep the Cone of Shame on the shelf for another week.
Let’s Get Back on Track
Week 11 wasn’t what we wanted, but at least we avoided a complete disaster.
Matt gave us a winning record, nobody went 0-3, and the Cone of Shame remains unused. We’ll take it.
Now we’ve got three popular picks to follow, a house divided on BYU-Kansas, and plenty of opportunities for someone to make a move in the standings. Caleb is still out front, but Craig and Matt are right behind him, and Zack is looking to get back into the mix.
We’re ready to turn the page and get back to winning weekends.
Week 12 is here!