For over a year, Jaden O’Neal has been the face of Oklahoma’s 2026 quarterback class. A four-star signal-caller with arm talent, mobility, and a passion for the game, O’Neal gave Brent Venables and the Sooners a strong early foothold at the most important position on the field.
Now, it looks like that foothold is slipping.
O’Neal recently wrapped up his official visit to Florida State, and not long after, a crystal ball prediction from a well-connected Seminoles insider projected a flip to Tallahassee. And while nothing is final, it’s hard to ignore the writing on the wall — especially when you consider the other piece of this quarterback puzzle.
That piece is Bowe Bentley, Oklahoma’s top target in recent months and the clear apple of new offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle’s eye. Bentley, a dynamic dual-threat from Celina, Texas, has been lighting it up on the national stage — including a jaw-dropping performance at the Elite 11 Finals. His rise, combined with OU’s full-throttle recruitment of him, has complicated O’Neal’s standing in the class.
To put it bluntly: Oklahoma is trying to have its cake and eat it too. And that approach may cost them a highly-rated QB in the process.
A Commitment Tested by Time and Transition
When Jaden O’Neal committed to OU in the summer of 2023, it was under then-offensive coordinator Seth Littrell. Since then, the Sooners have undergone another offensive transition, bringing in Ben Arbuckle from Washington State to modernize and energize their scheme.
To O’Neal’s credit, he remained loyal through the coaching turnover. Despite plenty of interest elsewhere, he kept his pledge and even reaffirmed it publicly multiple times.
But loyalty has its limits — especially when the school you’re committed to is openly courting another blue-chip quarterback at your position.
While it’s not uncommon for schools to take two QBs in a class, the vibe around the Bentley recruitment hasn’t exactly screamed “QB1A and QB1B.” Bentley is the centerpiece of Arbuckle’s vision. His Elite 11 showing only strengthened that narrative. Meanwhile, O’Neal is beginning to look like a fallback plan to some observers — even if the staff wouldn’t say it aloud.
That kind of energy can be felt by recruits. And clearly, Jaden O’Neal is feeling it.
Florida State Swoops In
Enter Mike Norvell and Florida State — a program without a quarterback committed in the 2026 cycle, but one that’s made O’Neal a top priority. Norvell has leaned into O’Neal’s skill set and offered something Arbuckle hasn’t: unquestioned QB1 status.
O’Neal’s quotes after his Florida State visit made it clear that he sees a strong fit in Tallahassee. He praised Norvell’s consistency, raved about the offensive scheme under Gus Malzahn (now OC at FSU), and spoke positively about the energy and cohesion of the staff. Perhaps more importantly, he sounded like a recruit who felt wanted — and seen.
“I feel like [Malzahn] uses the quarterback’s strength to the offense,” O’Neal said. “A lot of play-action, a lot of RPOs… I feel like I fit that part of the system.”
That kind of fit — combined with a perception that OU is hedging its bets — may be enough to push O’Neal out the door.
The Bentley Factor
There’s no denying Bowe Bentley is an elite talent. He accounted for over 4,000 total yards and 60+ touchdowns as a junior. He’s drawn comparisons to John Mateer for his dual-threat ability, and his Elite 11 performance only cemented his status as a top-10 QB nationally.
If Oklahoma lands Bentley, there will be plenty of excitement — and understandably so. He’s the kind of quarterback who could thrive in Arbuckle’s up-tempo, vertical attack.
But the risk here isn’t Bentley’s talent. It’s the cost of that pursuit.
By going all-in on Bentley while O’Neal is still in the fold, OU has potentially jeopardized its relationship with a top-15 quarterback who was first to commit and stayed loyal during change. That sends a message to future recruits, especially quarterbacks: your place isn’t secure, even if you commit early.
This isn’t just about O’Neal. It’s about the signal it sends to other QBs and their families watching this unfold.
What Happens Next?
If Bentley picks Oklahoma — and that decision could come soon — it’s likely that O’Neal flips to Florida State not long after. If Bentley picks LSU, OU may scramble to keep O’Neal from walking. But by then, it may be too late.
That’s the danger in playing the two-quarterback game in a world where loyalty is rare, and relationships matter.
Jaden O’Neal has done everything a program could ask of a committed quarterback. He’s produced, stayed steady through staff turnover, and engaged with the fanbase. Losing him now would sting — and if he thrives at Florida State while OU tries to develop its “Plan A,” that sting could linger for a long time.
Final Thought
In the end, Oklahoma must live with the consequences of its strategy. Pursuing Bentley makes sense on paper — he’s a blue-chip talent who fits Arbuckle’s scheme to perfection. But doing so without fully reassuring O’Neal that he’s still a central part of the plan has opened the door for Florida State to capitalize.
And that’s exactly what they’re doing.
In recruiting, as in football, hesitation kills. Right now, Oklahoma is hesitating between two quarterbacks — and it may end up with just one… the one they weren’t sure they still had.
Follow us on Instagram