The Cotton Bowl will be buzzing Saturday afternoon, and the stakes feel as big as ever. Oklahoma and Texas—two of college football’s bluebloods—are set to collide once again in the 121st edition of the Red River Rivalry. But as the Sooners prepare for their biggest test of the season, they do so under a cloud of uncertainty at the most important position on the field.
Oklahoma may be undefeated and ranked near the top of the SEC standings, but the question on every Sooner fan’s mind this week is simple: Will John Mateer play?
The Mateer Mystery
It’s hard to remember a season where Oklahoma’s fate felt so closely tied to one player. Quarterback John Mateer—the Washington State transfer who took the SEC by storm through the first month of the season—has been everything OU hoped he’d be: dynamic, composed, and electric with both his arm and legs.
Through four games, Mateer threw for 1,215 yards and six touchdowns while adding nearly 200 yards and five more scores on the ground. He gave Brent Venables’ team a true dual-threat weapon, and the Sooners’ offense hummed because of it.
Then came the thumb injury—suffered in the first quarter against Auburn. Surgery followed, and with it, a wave of anxiety across Sooner Nation.
Venables has remained deliberately cautious. “He’s on a progression,” the head coach said this week. “We’re not going to put him in harm’s way before he’s ready.” The message is clear: Mateer’s health comes first, even if the team must ride backup Michael Hawkins Jr. a little longer.
Still, optimism persists inside the building. According to multiple reports, Mateer is pushing to return against Texas. It’s the kind of competitive fire that defines great quarterbacks—but the final decision will come down to the training staff and Venables’ judgment.
Michael Hawkins: Calm in the Chaos
If Mateer can’t go, Michael Hawkins Jr. will once again step under center. And while the lights will be brighter than last week, his season debut against Kent State did prove he’s capable of handling the moment.
Hawkins didn’t need to play hero ball. He just needed to steer the ship, and he did exactly that—162 passing yards, no turnovers, and a 44–0 win that showcased his composure more than his stats.
That’s the formula this week, too.
Hawkins isn’t Mateer, and the Sooners don’t need him to be. What Oklahoma needs is efficiency, composure, and trust in the supporting cast. OU’s offense still features playmakers who can change a game: Tory Blaylock, Jaren Kanak, Isaiah Sategna, and Deion Burks all have the ability to stretch Texas’ defense.
If Hawkins can distribute the ball, let the defense work, and avoid the big mistake, the Sooners will have every chance to win this rivalry game—even without their star quarterback.
Defense Defines This Team
Lost in the quarterback talk is a simple truth: Oklahoma’s defense is elite.
Through six weeks, the Sooners have looked like the SEC’s most complete defensive unit. The front seven is deep, disciplined, and disruptive. The secondary is opportunistic and physical. It’s a Brent Venables hallmark, finally realized in full.
Opponents are averaging just over 11 points per game against Oklahoma, and Kent State’s zero on the scoreboard last week marked the first shutout of the season.
Linebacker Kip Lewis leads the defense in tackles and continues to play at an All-Conference level, anchoring a group that thrives on communication and pursuit. Gentry Williams has been lockdown defender, and Eli Bowen’s return is only going to make the Sooners stronger in coverage, forcing quarterbacks into hurried reads and mistakes.
That’s the advantage Oklahoma carries into this edition of the Red River matchup: defense travels, and defense shows up when emotions run high.
Arch Manning and the Texas Test
Across the field, Arch Manning leads a Texas offense searching for rhythm after an upset loss at Florida. Manning’s arm talent is undeniable, but he’s still learning how to read elite defenses and stay patient under pressure.
He’ll need both this weekend, because Oklahoma’s front will be relentless.
The Longhorns’ offensive line has been shaky in pass protection at times, and that’s where Venables will look to pounce. Expect aggressive fronts, disguised blitzes, and an effort to keep Manning uncomfortable in the pocket.
Texas has weapons—Ryan Wingo, DeAndre Moore Jr., and Parker Livingstone, who is expected to play despite a leg injury—but the Sooners believe their secondary can match up.
If Oklahoma’s defense can limit big plays and win early downs, it can dictate the tempo of this game and force Texas into uncomfortable third-and-long situations. That’s exactly where Venables wants them.
The Golden Hat & the Bigger Picture
This rivalry doesn’t need extra motivation, but it has plenty. It’s about pride, momentum, and statement-making in the SEC.
For Oklahoma, this game is another litmus test: are the Sooners truly built for championship-level adversity? Can they handle a storm of injuries, noise, and pressure—and still execute?
Venables believes so. “These are the moments you come to Oklahoma for,” he said this week. “The pageantry, the competition, the challenge—it’s what this program was built on.”
That message resonates because it captures what this game really is: a gut check. It’s less about who’s healthy and more about who’s hungry.
Keys to the Game
- Protect the Football.
Whether it’s Mateer or Hawkins, ball security is non-negotiable. Turnovers flip momentum in rivalry games faster than anything else. - Win the Trenches.
Oklahoma’s defensive line must control the point of attack, and the offensive line must hold up long enough for whoever’s under center to settle in. - Let the Defense Set the Tone.
If the Sooners can keep Texas under 24 points, history says they’ll win. - Trust the Run Game.
Blaylock and the running back rotation can help keep pressure off the quarterback and control the clock. - Finish Strong.
Rivalry games are emotional sprints that often come down to the fourth quarter. Execution and conditioning will determine who hoists the Golden Hat.
Final Thoughts
Whether John Mateer suits up or not, Oklahoma walks into Dallas with an identity. This team defends, it competes, and it doesn’t blink. That’s the hallmark of a contender.
If Mateer plays, OU gains its offensive spark back—play-action threats, downfield balance, and the kind of improvisation that can break a defense. But even if he doesn’t, this group is battle-tested enough to grind out a win behind its defense, ground game, and grit.
Saturday won’t just test Oklahoma’s talent. It’ll test its resolve.
And when the dust settles at the Cotton Bowl, we’ll know something important about Brent Venables’ team: whether the Sooners are just a quarterback away—or already built to rise above the chaos and keep chasing the SEC crown.
Matt Hofeld is a college football & softball analyst and contributor covering the SEC. Follow him for more Oklahoma and conference-wide analysis throughout the 2025 season.
Follow us on Instagram & Facebook