The Red River Rivalry never rests. It demands attention, intensity, and stakes — and this Saturday’s meeting between Oklahoma and Texas will deliver on all fronts. But for the Sooners, this edition carries extra weight. With John Mateer’s status upgraded to “probable” after his throwing-hand surgery, Oklahoma faces not just a rivalry game — it’s a barometer for whether this program is tethered to one quarterback or built to rise above adversity.
Mateer’s Return: Hope, Risk & Timing
On Wednesday, Mateer was labeled “questionable” and many assumed he wouldn’t suit up. Now the SEC’s Thursday availability report lists him as probable. That shift matters — especially for Sooner fans hoping to see their Heisman-contending signal-caller back in action. Before the injury, Mateer had thrown for 1,215 yards, 6 touchdowns, 3 interceptions, and rushed for 190 yards with 5 more scores — production that placed him among the brightest young stars in college football.
But the path to that return is littered with risk. The surgery was performed just days after the injury, and Mateer sat out the Kent State game while Michael Hawkins Jr. walked into his first start of the season. Venables has been careful in his language: “He’s doing his normal protocol. He’s done zero good-on-good work,” the coach stated. In other words: physical readiness is still uncertain. Venables also reiterated, “If you’re going to play, you have to do good on good … Throw some skelly. Hand the ball off. Play on third downs.”
That’s a critical distinction. Oklahoma may list Mateer as probable, but the real moment of truth comes during warmups. If he can’t complete live snaps, the coaching staff will have to make the decision many fans are holding their breath over: let him in, or ride Hawkins againn.
The spotlight naturally falls on Hawkins the moment Mateer’s name comes into question. His performance against Kent State was solid — 162 yards passing, 3 touchdowns, 33 yards on the ground, and no turnovers. That kind of clean efficiency is exactly what you want from a backup thrust into spotlight. As Venables put it, Hawkins “had good awareness, self-awareness. Corrected mistakes, showed leadership.”
But stepping in during rivalry week is a different beast. Hawkins doesn’t need to rescue the Sooners; he needs to manage the game, protect the football, and lean on the team’s defensive strength. If he does that, he gives Oklahoma a shot — even if the offense lacks Mateer’s explosiveness. Hawkins is not just a placeholder; he could verify whether this team is rooted in one player or built for depth.
One of the defining truths about this Oklahoma team is that its defense has become its backbone. While much of the conversation surrounds the offense, the reason the Sooners remain a formidable program amid uncertainty is the weeks of work on defense, line play, and schemes. Venables himself talked about lines of scrimmage being “really important” and emphasized that protection, running efficiency, and physical execution must hold up in all four quarters.
We shouldn’t overlook what he and his staff have built: a group of defenders who take pride, ownership, and identity seriously. When Venables says, “They like to work, they like to compete… for them to create their own identity,” he isn’t just offering buzzwords — he’s praising a defense that has earned trust, one that knows how to anchor a team in crunch time.
Let’s not pretend Texas is a pushover. Oklahoma knows this is a serious test. Venables gave hearty praise to the Longhorns in his opening remarks of this week’s media session. He noted that Texas’ offense carries balance — plenty of hurting weapons across the line, backfield, receivers, tight ends. He spoke favorably of the consistency in Sarkisian’s tenure, calling the program “a model of consistency the last several years.” He doubled down on the defense, pointing out their ability to quell Ohio State and maintain dominance throughout all phases of the season.
When it comes to Arch Manning, Venables took a measured tone but respected what he brings. He talked about Manning’s “toughness and courage … edginess, the response” and how he’s flashed dual-threat qualities — running through traffic, scrambling, showing arm strength when necessary. Oklahoma’s game plan will depend heavily on pressuring him. Venables said as much: “We’ve got to win up front and not allow the clock to be exponentially long.” The idea is simple — make Manning uncomfortable, disrupt his pocket presence, and force mistakes.
On the coaching front, Venables acknowledged that while schemes matter, execution wins. The matchup with Sarkisian’s offense is a test of discipline, fundamentals, and timing. “It’ll come down to that — it’s a player’s game,” he said.
There’s pageantry, television cameras, and 100-plus years of history tied to this rivalry. Venables, who first experienced Red River as an assistant under Stoops, said its emotion hasn’t faded:
“I don’t think there’s a better rivalry in all of college football … the pageantry … the passion … the history between the two programs … doesn’t ever get old.”
He noted that even after decades, the hate and the respect coexist. For Oklahoma, this game is about more than wins — it’s about restoring identity, demanding pride, and proving to the nation that they’re not bound by one injured player.
Oklahoma has one opportunity to redeem years of tough losses under Venables and reset the narrative. This isn’t just about Thursday’s injury report or Hawkins’ rise. It’s about whether Oklahoma can show the maturity and depth to absorb challenges, remain resilient, and still compete with one of its oldest rivals.
My opinion heading into this game: if Mateer plays, Oklahoma gains back a spark of unpredictability. The offense opens up, pressure eases on run game, and defenses must adjust. But the risk is real — a half-powered or still-healing Mateer could be worse than Hawkins managing the game cleanly.
If Hawkins is under center, Oklahoma’s best chance lies in relying on defense, special teams, methodical drives, and controlling the clock. The Sooners must lean into their strengths, resist hero ball, and keep Texas off balance.
Victory in Dallas with or without Mateer would be a seismic statement. A loss, especially a blowout, would raise more questions than answers. But the opportunity here is rare: Oklahoma can prove it’s not just a quarterback factory — it’s a program with depth, identity, and character.
Because perhaps more than ever, this game will validate whether Oklahoma is just chasing a quarterback — or already built to chase greatness.
Matt Hofeld is a college football & softball analyst and contributor covering the SEC. Follow him for more Oklahoma and conference-wide analysis throughout the 2025 season.
Follow us on Instagram & Facebook