The End of an Era: Why Oklahoma State Was Right to Part Ways with Mike Gundy

For nearly two decades, Mike Gundy was more than a football coach at Oklahoma State. He was the program’s constant—its builder, its showman, and, for many fans, its identity. When news broke Tuesday that the university had fired Gundy after a string of embarrassing losses, the college football world reacted with shock, nostalgia, and, in some quarters, relief. For OSU’s athletic leadership, however, the move was less about sentiment than survival.

A Program in Freefall

No matter how deep a coach’s roots, college football is ultimately a results business. And the results in Stillwater had reached a breaking point. The Cowboys finished 3-9 in 2024, their first losing season since Gundy’s debut year in 2005, and failed to make a bowl game for the first time in nearly two decades. That collapse spilled into 2025, where a 69-3 humiliation at Oregon was followed by a 19-12 home loss to Tulsa—the program’s first defeat to the Golden Hurricane in Stillwater since 1951.

Those numbers aren’t just bad luck or rebuilding pains; they’re evidence of a program that had lost its competitive edge. When a Big 12 team becomes a double-digit home favorite over a Group of Five opponent and still loses, alarms go off. In that sense, Tuesday’s firing was less a surprise than a recognition of reality.

The Paradox of Mike Gundy

That reality is hard to square with Gundy’s legacy. A three-time Big 12 Coach of the Year, he is OSU’s winningest coach, with a 170-90 record and 12 bowl victories. He delivered a conference championship in 2011, oversaw some of the most explosive offenses in school history, and developed quarterbacks like Brandon Weeden and Mason Rudolph who went on to NFL careers.

As athletic director Chad Weiberg put it in announcing the move: “Cowboy Football reached an unprecedented level of success and national prominence under Coach Gundy’s leadership … we are grateful for all he did to raise the standard and show us all what is possible for Oklahoma State football.”

Those words are true. They also underscore why the decision was so painful. But legacies don’t win third downs. They don’t patch up a porous defense. They don’t bring back disillusioned fans. At some point, the goodwill of the past stops insulating a coach from the failures of the present. For Gundy, that point arrived last weekend.

A Series of Missteps

Even before the on-field collapse, cracks had begun to show. Gundy’s sometimes-combative public persona—once a charming “I’m a man, I’m 40” rallying cry—had turned into a liability. In 2020, a T-shirt controversy briefly alienated players and alumni. Last winter, after a 52-0 season-ending loss at Colorado, Gundy lashed out at fans criticizing the program’s direction, then had to apologize weeks later.

Meanwhile, his reluctance to fully embrace the transfer portal until recently left OSU playing roster catch-up in an era of hyper-mobility. The 2025 roster had more than 60 newcomers, many from other programs, but the infusion of talent didn’t translate into immediate cohesion or wins. Gundy himself admitted Monday: “It’s not all the players. Coaches have to do a better job … I think it’s a two-way street.”

Those remarks, made barely 24 hours before his dismissal, now read like an unintended concession. In today’s college football, there is no patience for multi-year rebuilds. There’s only next Saturday and the scoreboard.

Why Firing Gundy Makes Sense

The simple answer is that Oklahoma State had plateaued and then collapsed. Once a model of consistency, the Cowboys became a cautionary tale: a program clinging to its past while the sport evolved around it. A fresh voice, a fresh system, and a fresh recruiting pitch are now imperative if OSU wants to avoid being permanently relegated to Big 12 middle-class status.

Firing a legend always risks alienating donors and alumni. But the cost of inertia—lost ticket sales, weaker recruiting classes, declining national profile—can be even greater. By making a clean break now, OSU signals it still aspires to contend for championships, not simply trade on memories of 2011.

The Search Ahead

Interim coach Doug Meacham will guide the team against Baylor this weekend, but the search for a permanent replacement is already a hot topic. The university’s leadership has not publicly named candidates, but the rumor mill is churning.

Offensive minds like Arkansas’s Kendall Briles, Oregon’s Will Stein, or even a high-profile wildcard like Joe Brady could reinvigorate OSU’s attack. Others point to Group of Five risers such as Eric Morris of North Texas or GJ Kinne of Texas State, who have built high-octane offenses and know the recruiting terrain of Texas and Oklahoma. Some fans even dream of a reunion with Dana Holgorsen, now at Nebraska, or of luring OSU alum Zac Robinson from the NFL.

Each name represents a trade-off between experience, recruiting reach, and cultural fit. But all share one trait Gundy no longer offered: the sense of forward momentum.

The Human Side of a Breakup

For all the speculation, Tuesday’s news also carried a heavy emotional weight. Gundy is not just a former coach but a former OSU quarterback whose entire adult life has been intertwined with the program. He guided the Cowboys from regional relevance to national recognition, put Stillwater on the map for offensive fireworks, and became one of the sport’s longest-tenured figures.

University president Jim Hess acknowledged that impact in his own statement: “Coach Gundy dedicated decades of his life to OSU, achieving significant success and positively impacting hundreds of young men who wore the OSU uniform. His contributions … deserve our profound respect and will not be forgotten.”

For fans who grew up on his teams, the firing marks the end of an era as much as a coaching change. That’s why the reaction across social media ranged from sadness to gratitude to outright anger. In Stillwater, Mike Gundy wasn’t just any coach. He was the coach.

Moving On

Yet college football, perhaps more than any other sport, thrives on reinvention. Iconic coaches leave and programs regenerate. Oklahoma State’s challenge now is to turn the page without losing its identity. The school’s facilities, fan base, and Big 12 affiliation still make it an attractive job. Its next coach inherits a roster with untapped talent and a conference that, while competitive, is wide open for a well-run program to rise.

That’s the opportunity OSU’s administration has chosen: a chance to reshape the program before mediocrity becomes permanent. For Gundy, the dismissal may be an unwelcome jolt but also an opportunity to recalibrate his own career. At 58, he’s too accomplished and too recognizable to remain unemployed for long.

Conclusion: A Necessary Goodbye

The firing of Mike Gundy is as much about the future as it is about the past. It honors his legacy by refusing to let it curdle into decline. It gives Oklahoma State a chance to rediscover the edge it once had under his leadership. And it serves as a reminder that even the most enduring relationships in college football are subject to the scoreboard.

For nearly 20 years, Mike Gundy defined Oklahoma State football. On Tuesday, the university chose to define its future without him. It’s a bittersweet but, ultimately, necessary decision—one that reflects both respect for what he built and urgency to build something new.

Matt Hofeld is a college football analyst and contributor covering the Big 12. Follow him for more Oklahoma State and conference-wide analysis throughout the 2025 season.

Follow us on Instagram